CitySearchNYC Explore the city with our editors
Whaddya want?
Nothing Now
Music
October 9, 1998
CitySearch Music!



Ask Mr. Diva!

Omniscient though I may be, there are some pressing musical questions even I cannot answer. To fill the gaps in my knowledge--and yours--I have recruited the elegant, erudite Mr. Diva, who is perhaps familiar to those of you who frequent the couture floor of Saks Fifth Avenue and the back rows of the Gaiety Burlesque. Allow Mr. Diva to enlighten you on the finer points of the, ahem, proclivities, of the Backstreet Boys, as well as the truth about Bette (Davis, not Midler) and why not all queens are bitches and all bitches certainly ain't queens....

Dear Mr. Diva,
Which of the Backstreet Boys is top, and which is bottom? Please answer swiftly, as a round of martinis hangs on the accuracy of my guesstimation.
--Gineva


Dear Gineva,
Top, bottom, bottom, top. Isn’t it amusing how, in a world of choices, all the choices are the same?

Before we begin, Mr. Diva points out that, for purposes of this essay, the terms “boy” or “girl group” refer not to those staffed by frontspeople who can actually sing, play an instrument, or write music. A “boy-” or “girl group” is created by labels and/or PR firms and sustained by cunning producers, with the "musicians" functioning as nothing other than rhythmic cake decoration. That some of the survivors of this machine have achieved spectacular careers can be attributed to a) their talent being bigger than the package offered, and b) the superior wisdom of Mr. Diva, identifying such legends where appropriate, dragging them out of the bar or 12-step program, and gently shoving same back into the spotlight.

Boy- and girl-groups belong to the great tradition of Junk Rock, that self-referential art form whose charm, and essence, is its very disposability. Whereas Ronnie Spector’s smoky, quavering alto only improves with every shot of tequila she downs, Jimmy Osmond’s sugary falsetto must, of necessity, transmute. Junk Rock groups of both sexes represent a powerful presence which alleviates teenagers’ angst while extorting their allowance from their pockets. Just as every generation has its collective neurosis, so does every decade have its girl and boy group. Being entirely a phenomenon of a teenage audience--and teenagehood being measured not in physical years but placement along the continuum of maturity--the boy group du jour offers a clearer distillation of the collective unconscious than the top ten grossing slasher flicks of any given year.

Time passes, and the wheat loses no time in separating itself from the chaff. In other words, whereas Frankie Valli can still pack a theatre in Atlantic City, none but the most die-hard fan would still Roll in Bay City. With few exceptions, the legends of boy grouphood have not been as thoroughly catalogued as their compatriots of the X chromosome. What we really need (and Mr. Diva means no offense to dahling Ronnie) is for those good folks at Rhino Records to curate an anthology of bare-not-hair-chested falsetto pop, performed in what would be five-part harmony if more than two of the parts could actually harmonize.

Right on schedule, the 1990’s have birthed the Backdoor Boys. Mr. Diva, not entirely trusting his objectivity where well-groomed lads with taut abdomens are concerned, conducted a straw-poll among his numerous friends, balancing the conventional wisdom against his personal appraisal. The results, appended below, confirm everything he suspected.

Nick (Vanilla Spice), being both the youngest Backdoor Boy and an Aquarius, is the group’s swing. The evidence of this is the excessive sissiness of his floppy blond haircut juxtaposed against his predilection for basketball drag. The standard deviation for this inference is plus/minus ten. Also involving his youth, Vanilla Spice is the group’s most compulsive, or at least most reliable, masturbator. This makes him likeliest to switch roles mid-frug and most excited about doing so. The standard deviation for this inference is zero.

Brian (Cardio Spice) expends the most energy during tearful l-u-v songs and wears the most blatant Chelsea Boy haircut. He purveys the deepest chasm of faux sensitivity even as his eyes crinkle from the depths of his self-absorption. He is a card-carrying top, with intermittent lapses into bottoming when Vanilla Spice wants a chance to plug. The standard deviation for these inferences is zero. On those occasions when pluggers outnumber plugees, Cardio Spice runs the video camera.

Kevin (Bluegrass Spice) is a self-confessed farm boy, meaning his first sexual experiences were with watermelons and cooperative livestock. Such a wholesome upbringing invariably results in an unsophisticated sexual palate, thus Bluegrass is a top, and a helluva top at that. However, the standard deviation for this inference is plus/minus fifteen, for the fluidity with which Bluegrass Spice shakes his hips during those dance-flavored aerobics routines indicates that it may be he who puts the backstreet in the boys.

Howie D (Frankenspice) is a jiggin’ monument to mixed signage, being the most overtly macho in presentation but the girliest singer. As such, Frankenspice invokes the “butch in the streets/fem between the sheets” rule, virtually embodying the great tradition of bottoming. As any male who’s experienced it will verify, there’s nothing like having one’s prostate massaged to cause one to sing high, loud, and proud. The standard deviation for this inference is plus/minus seven.

AJ (Taco Seasoning) is the blandest of the bland: a straight bottom. Witness the cookie-cutter averageness of his facial foliage and lack of muscle tone below the abs. His standard deviation is none.

You are going to need those martinis, Gineva--whoever’s buying. The superpopularity of the Backdoor Boys offers reason enough for the more delicate among us to hide under the covers with the blinds drawn.

Let us link hands. Gineva, you have surely been haunted by videos, mocked by racks of magazine covers, cursed by unprecedented airplay. We recall with significant horror the video in which the Boys dance the monster mash, without evidencing a shred of awareness that they channel the precocity of youth via the Groovie Ghoulies. Oh, yea, they are monsters. Gaze upon them and be afraid. Be very afraid.
--Mr. Diva

   

Dear Mr. Diva,
Re Bette Midler (Ask Mr. Diva, August 19), that’s real nice, but I meant Bette Davis.
--Antonio

Dear Ant’ny,
Bette Davis
indeed. Ha ha. We will have our little joke, won’t we? Mr. Diva is certain you are one of those department store snipers who attempt to relieve customers of three months’ worth of drug-and-booze money during one trip to the counter. Listen, buster, Mr. Diva can spot jokers from miles away. Mr.Diva has observed you, often with your name tag still affixed, saluting your skinflute in that same department store’s remotest men’s room.

As you are fully aware, Miz Davis is one of the all-time grandes-dames of divahood, an apex of sisterhood shared by rare and august company including Pam Grier and Cleopatra. Divahood pushed to the nth degree becomes megadivahood (MDH in the industry). MDH has surpassed all acid tests of mere divahood, including bad men, bad movies, and bad hair, to land smack dab in the middle of bad attitude. A megadiva hides razor blades in her afro, keeps a basket of asps by the throne, can render an Academy-Award winning leading man into a supporting player in two seconds flat.

Miz Davis has carved a special place in this pantheon. Louise Brooks had long since turned to avocational cannibalism when Bette stormed Tinseltown, took one look around, and pronounced with chilling authority that the place was a dump. From this pronouncement, she forged history by playing the hell out of every archetype from slattern to harridan, gathering along the way Oscars, the SAG presidency, and a legendary feud with Joan Crawford, whom Bette affectionately called “Whore of Babylon.”

Next time you find yourself in Blockbuster’s “Classics” section, Mr. Diva recommends the following. The early years: “Of Human Bondage,” in which Bette sports a nimbus Patti LaBelle would have envied; and “Dangerous,” in which Bette gives her first on-screen lesson in messing up other people’s lives. The Golden Years: "Mr. Skeffington,” in which Bette plays one of the first modern heroines, a legendary beauty whom everyone wants only for her money; and, naturally, “Now Voyager,” in which Bette suffers worse than Mildred Pierce with a migraine but discovers the weaponry, and rewards, of couture.

Then there are the two roles which catapulted Bette from just another chain-smoking, foul-mouthed bitch into the stratosphere of MDH. In “All About Eve,” Bette vamps like Tallulah on angel dust, making herstory by being a woman playing a woman in female drag. In “Whatever Happened to Baby Jane?,” Bette’s grand-guignol turn as Baby Jane Hudson practically handed Anthony Hopkins his Oscar--thirty years before and a few chomosomes away from the fact. And he didn't even thank her.

Finally, to answer the question with which you thought you’d stump Mr. Diva, Bette Midler’s namesake did dabble musically. She allieviates the tedium of Dinah Shore in the wartime musical “Thank Your Lucky Stars” by grinding her nicotine-scarred tenor through a production number for, and about, our boys in uniform. Mr. Diva has ascertained that her record, “Miss Bette Davis Sings,” is, like Ethel Merman’s disco album, not available on CD. Let us all thank our lucky stars. If anyone hears differently, please don’t let Mr. Diva know.

However, as every diva-worshipper knows, Miz Davis’ greatest moment was her final yahoo at the Academy Awards, and not just because she had the balls to wear an apricot fright wig. You see, Miz Davis had been contracted to give the Best Picture Oscar--this during a decade when they made almost no good pictures, forget about best. Well, Miz Davis ignored, or perhaps couldn’t focus on, the teleprompter and launched into a landmark tirade about “The Sound of Music” (30+ years after the film’s release), all while looking and sounding like one of the wicked trees in "The Wizard of Oz." Even Mama Diva, who has been known to display an attitude of her own, was impressed.

You have now learned the secret handshake of MDH: survival. Mr. Diva hopes he’s not too late in relaying the message.

By the way, dahling, Mr. Diva needs to return that lipstick you sold him. It simply doesn’t leave enough of a stain on his cigarette.
--Mr. Diva

 

Dear Mr. Diva,
Does one have to be a Bitch to be a Queen?
--Kat

Dahling Kat,
Mr. Diva likes you. You forego such unimportant national dialogue as the presidential cumrag in favor of issues that really matter. Please phone Mr. Diva’s social secretary to schedule lunch.

Just as in fine tailoring there are buttons and there are buttons, in divadom there are queens and there are queens. One kind of queen, inconvenienced by a penis, spends his life making up for the fact that he never got to be a cheerleader in high school. The other kind of queen never had a penis but still didn’t make the squad--because she never wanted to. During the golden days, these two varieties of social deviant forged one magnificent, acid-laced social strata. Arm in arm, queens romped with queens, laughing hysterically at Dolce & Gabanna’s latest collection, howling over each other’s Dierdre Hall scrapbooks, monitoring each other’s bad boyfriends and cellulite.

Now, Mr. Diva always knew that not all queens were bitches. But he never thought he’d live to see the day when one could be a bitch without being a queen. Being a queen and being a bitch require both homework and teamwork, a discerning eye and a sharp tongue. But we are tragically mired in times where the lines are so blurred that no migraine, no unprecedented weight gain, no torrid love affair even raises eyebrows, much less hones wit. How, then, are we going to train queens to wield the double-edged sword of bitchery?

Divas are products of their times. Divas define while being defined. Diva-worshippers latch onto idols for guidance, inspiration, courage, and make-up tips. How can such a vital and delicate flower, which depends upon the hothouse atmosphere of society, survive in precarious times?

We thought we had it figured out by, say, 1988. The counter-culture was dead, the wind beneath Bette’s wings was the flatulence of a Disney deal, Cher was winning Oscars, and no one thought the idea of Dolly becoming her own theme park was redundant. We took a collective look around and realized that we were at the tail-end of a decade which offered, for posterity’s delectation, Molly Ringwald.

Flash-forward to 1992. An impressionable sissy steps off the bus from Sphincterville ready to dip his toenails in the river of fabulousness. Looks around. The river, alas, has run dry. That fruit turns sour. Instantly, now believing that his natural pissiness--not his regal stature or even superior taste--entitles him to bitchood.

The informal motto of the 1990’s, “been there, done that” is inaccurate. What we really mean is “been nowhere, done nothing, and don't know the difference." For proof, Mr. Diva offers, alas, another personal anecdote. During a recent public appearance, Mr. Diva actually witnessed a supplicant compare Mr. Diva’s artfully constructed look du jour to the Widder Cobain. Mr. Diva, of course, was insulted, but even more horrifying is that this supplicant assumed such a comparison was a compliment. In other words, dahling, we live in a society so undiscerning that a disrespectful old rag such as Rolling Stone puts Courtney on the same cover as Madonna and Tina Turner. Breathing the same air! And no one blinks!

The waiter (whom we saw teabagging our second-best boyfriend at Champs two weeks earlier) is late with our white-radish-and-key-lime couscous and must be assassinated. Salespeople cower when they draw our names for cold-calling, for we have carefully cultivated the image that we raise cobras as a hobby. We no longer check out each other’s baskets at the gym but the tensile strength of our tummy-tucks. We arm ourselves with cosmopolitans and Nat Shermans and shoot ice cubes through our eyes and bleed anti-freeze when we cut ourselves shaving. We are in the unspeakable position of inflaming snidery without training royalty. Why? Because we’re sick and tired of being sick and tired.

You don’t believe Mr. Diva? If the nineties had supplied us with more divas, our bad moods would be better and your question, though pertinent, would be moot. Queens would be defined by royal attitude rather than sexual cargo. Bitchiness would be correctly identified as a core competency of queendom instead of an independent adjunct. We would jettison this ridiculous “been there done that” zeitgeist in favor of actually going somewhere and doing something. Our bitchery would have style, flair, elegance, not bitterness. We would all be in on the joke instead of turning it on ourselves. If queens--men, women, and all genders in between--would meld bitchiness back into our demeanor and temper it with the intelligence of observation and the warmth of experience, we would save society as a whole. You require tinder for your flame? Listen to either "Mechanical Animals" or "Celebrity Skin" (your choice). Mr. Diva rests his case
--Mr. Diva

 
Mr. Diva takes on the most complex subjects and gives them names. Partake of his wisdom while he's in a generous mood by e-mailing here.

Next Week: CMJ Preview

Previously:
17 reasons why The Beastie Boys are wack!

North By Northwest (Not the Movie)

Dead Elvis: Munching The King's Corpse

Fear of a Black Planet: The Goth Revival.

Horoscopes for the Week of July 20.

Spice Girls review, Fourth of July disasters, an obscene love triangle, and all-star hope for our nation's future.

Brooklyn hip hop, Detroit techno, mermaids, zombies, lounge singers, the "Wonderboy Preacher," and full frontal nudity.

Horoscopes for the week of June 22.

Courtney Love sucks and some of the reasons why.

The Jon Spencer Blues Explosion, the Lounge Lizards, and Afrika Bambataa & the SoulSonic Force.

The legendary Ginger Spice rant!

Frank Sinatra & Ava Gardner.



 


Send feedback here.